==========
(Posted to cheap-shelters 04/04)
==========
Laren: "You should be able to also form that central ring with wood, if you cut accurately, perhaps strap it with nailing plates, and/or gusset it very well on the inside and out with plywood, all around."
==========
Agreed. I just thought some 3/16" flat plate by 4" or so could be curved into an 18" circle and welded. Smaller box steel has the same I.D. as a typical 2X so it's fairly straight forward to remove one wall of the "box" and create a U-shaped clip to receive the end of the rib. Circumference of this ring is about 56.5 inches so if we allow 2" for each rib clip, it would leave about 1-5/8" of space between the clips (which also gives us some idea of how close together these ribs end up being as they near the peak -- small wonder these dome shapes are so inherently strong). Prior to welding the clip in place, I'd want to pre-drill it for screws or bolts to hold the rib. I'm not a welder but two of my friends are -- one is a production welder at a utility trailer plant -- either of them could knock one of these out in a few hours so that would make it REAL easy for me!
==========
Laren: "I agree. Two smart workers, with electricity, who know how to hustle, could get it done, fairly quickly. It is all basically repeating the same light work. Could even be a rather pleasant job. Good work needs a little
thinking to it, or the boredom will get to you."
==========
A good stereo helps . . . unless one of you is addicted to classic rock and the other to country; then things can get a little testy . . . but at least not boring. My electrician friend and I were working on a project together for a few days. The "primary" was a country fan and the music was loud and always on. We're both classic rockers and the last day he said, "You know how they call that stuff S&*#-kickin' music?" I said, "Yeah." Then he said, "That's cuz' after listening to it for a few days, you just wanna' kick the S&*# out of somebody!"
==========
People who don't talk much can sure be funny as hell when they finally decide to say something.
==========
Laren: "Did you look at that big round barn? They had a long ditch where they soaked the boards for their site laminated rafters, and curved sheathing. Board sheathing also leaves a lot of open space, for intricate shapes, can be faster than having to cut plywood to flex around bends."
==========
I guess I missed that one. Was that one of your links? I'd like to look at it. The plans I have for site-laminated gothic arch rafters are simply "cold-bent" around blocks on the floor and glued and nailed in place. Of course, they're only 1X2s in that design so they bend easily. Seems like soaking 'em would interfere with the glue bond unless they let 'em dry bent and THEN glue 'em together? That huge gothic-arch barn in MEN was simply sheeted with 1" T&G -- flexible AND the boards can borrow strength from each other. The rafters for it were "cold bent" as well.
==========
Laren: "You could use lapped ridges so that you only have to cut one side. I really like that for valleys. I have not had a chance to try it on ridges, but I see no reason that it would not work quite well. Just do the second lap
away from weather, as you do with all roofing laps. Caps are pretty much just for looks with sealing shingles, anyway.
==========
With valleys -- especially if the bottom eaves of both sides of the valley are flush -- you can weave the shingle rows together and not cut either side. Installers kinda' hate it 'cause you have to roof both sides of a valley at the same time which involves a lot of extra time and effort. More typically, they'll run one side "wild" with the excess flaring up the opposite deck. Then they'll run the 2nd side "wild" with the excess overlapping the already roofed first deck. Then they snap a line and cut through the top layer only. This gives a straight valley "line" for a cleaner look than the weaving method. Of course, valley metal is another option -- and method -- where accumulating rooftop debris is a problem.
==========
With ridges, even though running a first layer "wild" and then overlapping it would be functional as a roof, the overlap angles DOWN the roof and would tend to "peek out" between finished rows. The added thickness of even running one side wild and cutting the second side isn't acceptable for us died-in-the-wool purist types and would be inconsistent and visible in the finished roof.
==========
Laren: "It would be a lot easier to use 90# rolled roofing. On most structures you could even run it vertically, if the facets were no wider than 3'. For wider facets, run it horizontally like huge shingles. Horizontal application will also
be more material conservative, because the angle cuts can be used for the next piece. Ridge capping would be in long strips. You can even get colors, if you search around, but white would make the most energy sense."
==========
I DO like this idea. Roll roofing is one of the last great classic values in roofing ($14.95 for 100 s/f = 15 cents a square foot . . . only twice the cost of 30 # felt!) and can be very serviceable IF folks don't rush it and give this stuff time to warm and flatten out smooth BEFORE it is nailed on. I think it also makes a great "emergency roof" in place of felt which can be shingled over "later" -- sometimes that later ends up being 20 years later! Whenever you see wrinkles in this stuff on an existing roof, it's because someone got in a hurry and didn't allow sufficient time for the material to warm and acclimate. The vertical installation (what we call "farmer style") on the "pallet dome" would work nicely if the maximum facet width is kept under 3'. For better visuals, though, I'd be inclined to use a conventional ridge cap: in either a matching color or a color with pleasing contrast. It's impossible to get cut edges to match the clean edge of factory edges. It's true, with horizontal application -- every cut could count so the potential is there for almost no waste BUT even the full exposure roll roofing has a 2" salvage edge which is usually covered by the next layer. So in alternating -- to take advantage of every angled cut -- this salvage edge would be exposed on every other facet and would need to be trimmed off for acceptable visuals. (But, of course, if you're gonna' shingle over it "later" -- who cares?) Again -- hard to get a clean cut -- especially on lighter-colored material cuz' the black asphalt emulsion tends to get squished out and irregular as you cut the warm material from the back (almost impossible to cut from the front).
==========
Laren: "Another alternative would be to just cut every tab to use as separate shingles. There is an interesting visual advantage to this approach. It allows you to vary the coursing to achieve a look that obscures the ridges almost completely, and let you further 'shape' the roof. Like these cedar shingles, that vary the courses, and even pile the scrap shingles under, to create a bumpy surface, in an old technique called "pyramiding".
==========
The pre-perforated shingles -- manufactured to be easily used for ridge cap -- would be perfect for this. I don't know if they cost more or not. One pattern I find particularly attractive is with even and parallel rows but every other row only exposes 2" instead of the standard 5-5/8" or so. Takes more shingles but a truly classic look. Another classic look -- which you've mentioned before -- is where every other shingle is spaced up an inch or so . . . a look some folks call "hounds tooth." Shingles can last a very long time on surfaces which are more wall than roof IF you can keep kids from tugging at them and pulling the loose corners off!
==========
Laren: "When I first joined cheap-shelters I did a long post about freespan Half-Gambrel trusses, and how they could be radiused in any number of facets, and even ascendingly spiraled around a central shaft, or chimney/utility
core, like a spiral stairs or chambered nautilus. I think, at that time, my message may have just been misconstrued, as anti--dome trolling, and the true essence of what I was trying to say, about alternative systems for faceted structures, seemed to have gotten lost in the smoke. It is complicated, but there is no limit to the shaping that can be done. With a sturdy interior support, which could even extend up through the roof, You could pour a very irregular, wandering footing, and lay each segmented pallet-truss out on the spot to give you a sculpted wall, which could easily vary its height, slope, base, number of facets, curve, etc, literally all of its shape characteristics. A combination of fitted sheathing, followed by any one of a variety of methods to smooth out the variations, and fine tune the shape. That last stage could be done with wood shingles, or with Nelda's concept of using salvaged extruded polystyrene, then spraycrete."
==========
I think of these options as an upside-down cupcake liner. You can squish it around and form any shape you want. Personally, I got lured into this pallet quonset concept with concerns for economy and simplicity of design. Like you, I've become fascinated with the flexibility and possibilities -- it's great fun to play with lines and notice how the simplest changes can have a dramatic effect on how something looks. But I NEED to keep it simple and I have to keep smacking myself in the head with my KISS hammer to hold the line.
==========
Having said that, I've noticed a wide variety in the framing lumber LENGTH of these pallets I've gathered for free. Lots of 4', 5' -- even 6' pieces. As size groups make themselves more apparent, I've envisioned pre-cutting rafter segments at 1' intervals. Some 3' -- some 4' -- some 5', etc. When I have 56 of any one length, that gives me enough for ONE facet down both sides of my 36' long shelter. I hate to, but I can always cut the longer ones shorter if I have to.
==========
My neighbors are already giving me the evil eye -- or maybe it's just a touch of paranoia -- but the plan is to disassemble the pallets as quickly as possible and precut framing and sheathing and stack my embarrassingly low-cost components neatly inside my garage and out of sight. That way, firewood and campfire debris can be stacked and organized and I can see at a glance how my project is going. And things will always look "neat" from the street -- part of the price we pay (for now) of living in Suburbia.
==========
Laren: "These shapes bring up other issue, like roof venting for moisture and excessive heat control. A none vented roof is usually not a roof that will maintain its insulation value, will likely rot, and lose it structural integrity
prematurely, and it may also grow toxic black mold. Due to the water and vapor seal of the exterior roofing this situation should never be confused with the far more forgiving nature of walls. It is very different. And, the problems that occur are also a lot worse, Condensation does not stay hidden, It wets your interior finish, and ceiling DO fall down. That ususally happens way before
the structure fails, but rot can take out the whole roof."
==========
I'm VERY meticulous with vapor barriers on the warm side of any insulation but moisture still finds its way inside sooner or later and provision must be made for that moisture to safely escape as quickly as possible. In our extremely dry, edge-of-the-desert climate -- it's not the issue it is in moister areas but it's STILL an issue. How do you recommend we vent this thin shell filled with fiberglass insulation? I know air moving across fiberglass compromises R-value as fiberglass is intended to function in a dead-air space. Do we need a double-deck roof? Or can I install housewrap on the outside of the ribs, lay down 1X2 or 2X2 furring strips -- and then secure the sheathing to the furring strips? This would create a 1" or 2" gap which could be covered with 1/8" mesh at the eave and then vented at the ridge with a continuous ridge vent or an elevated "Sun Valley Vent" which runs the length of the roof supported by 2X4s on edge.
==========
Another advantage of such a vented deck is in the summer as it begins to warm up, natural air convection carries much of the solar heating up and away before it has a chance to heat up the insulation and the sheetrock (or whatever interior finish there might be). This saves the shelter from excessive heating that much longer AND a cooler roof deck makes shingles last longer . . . an added bonus. Unfortunately -- in the winter -- there is a trade-off. Heat which gets through the interior finish and the insulation is also wisked away that much quicker. But perhaps this is a small price to pay for a wood structure which will last a very long time IF it is kept dry.
==========
Laren: "I have learned how to fully vent just about any shape, and even vent
around roof openings like skylights, chimneys, dormers, etc. and jack rafters without venting the hip ridges (a no-no in snow country)."
==========
I can see how ice dams combined with vented hip ridges would just let the water pour in. Ice dams aren't a problem everywhere and they're not a problem here every year but when they ARE a problem, rain gutters get ripped off with wild abandon and gutter-heating cables fly off the shelves. Better homes -- and the more conscientious roofers -- install a row of "snow shield" at the wet edges to combat this problem. State buildings require it at ALL roof edges, valleys, etc. which crosses over into "massive overkill" but I'd probably do the same if I could get someone else to pay for it.
==========
> Small windows which fit within any one facet might not be
> too bad but doors require vertical "boxes" to be glommed
> on somehow unless one wants to be completely radical and
> access the dome through an elevated floor like the beavers do!
==========
Laren: "Cool!....I like it.......you are a true creative thinker ;O)"
==========
Thanks for the orchids -- that's a definite compliment coming from someone with your talent and abilities.
==========
Laren: "If this seems like an aesthetic frivolity, think about how much easier it
would be to just use the pallets for a rectaliniear structure. Aesthetics
is at the heart of the very structure. Even the lowliest of shelters must have a heart."
==========
With the wide variety of pallets I'm getting, it's not at all clear how they could be used intact for much of anything like a rectalinear structure. Most of them have decking boards that are loose and damaged -- it's a labor of love to separate the good from the firewood. Shorter pieces of lumber almost demand a multi-faceted shape to fully exploit their lack of stature. I completely agree about aesthetics and heart -- a structure can be simple and small and frugal but it doesn't have to look like something thrown together by drunk students piling up pallets for a bonfire.
==========
Laren: "I think almost all good pallet design/build will hide them. They are seldom attractive, even in a crude way, and there is little consistency. Your segmented truss system sure hides them completely."
==========
For me, that is most of the fun -- building something nice out of free wood. Something SO nice that when it's done, no one will believe it was made from free pallet wood. It's that balancing point where workmanship makes ALL the difference and I find that particularly rewarding. I've never had the money to just go out and buy new materials whenever I wanted to build something for myself, so I've always saved every door, every window, every shingle, every scrap chunk of 2X4 I could get my hands on. If it's too short to make a block, I can always toss it in the stove for some free heat.
==========
> I need something much more permanent to justify
> all the time I'm "wasting" carefully taking all these
> pallets apart.
==========
Laren: "Then, think about venting it ;O)"
==========
Good advice -- I'll be counting on you to help me figure out the best, low-cost way to vent the pallet quonset/gothic arch shape.
==========
sail4free
==========